In a perfect world, the reputation of any given credit union would precede it, and people would flock from far and wide to join. Not a dime would be spent on marketing.
Unfortunately, it’s not a perfect world: kids are eating Tide Pods, Firefly was canceled after one season, and it costs money to attract new credit union members. Acquisition costs are real.
Any credit union growth strategy is going to rely on marketing to get the message out about their services. The real question is, how much does a new member cost? And, just as importantly, is it worth it?
One of the more telling issues that we’ve repeatedly seen is that credit unions don’t know how much it costs to acquire a new member. Probably, this is because of two variables.
This is the most common reason why credit unions don’t have solid numbers for member acquisition costs. There is no set methodology for calculating member acquisition costs. Each credit union might include different variables.
For example, one credit union might consider only the cost of advertisements, banner ads, newspapers, email campaigns, and the like. Another credit union might add in a portion of their marketing team’s salaries or the cost of their online account opening platform. You might want to include operations’ salaries and the cost of any conference or speaking engagement as well. Yet another credit union may read the cost somewhere and call it good.
Pro tip: if you’re in the last party, I’ll save you some time right now:
We typically see the average new credit union member acquisition cost sit somewhere between $400 and $700.
This is where things get really tricky. Depending on the market, different account types may be easier or more difficult to market to.
In a bull market, there’s more monetary velocity. Businesses see good profits, unemployment falls, and the paychecks are fat. People are willing to spend money because they can count on more money coming in.
When the market is strong, credit union member acquisition costs for loan accounts is much easier. More people are ready to improve or buy houses, purchase new cars, and so on. They’re already looking for the best loan terms out there, so it doesn’t take as much nurturing to convince someone to open an account.
It can be easier to attract members for loan accounts than for deposit accounts in a bull market. That’s because instead of finding better ways of saving, people are finding better ways of spending.
However, in bear markets, the opposite is true. Fewer people splurge on a new car when the economy’s in the dump. Fortunately, it’s easier to attract new members for deposit accounts when the market is bad. That’s because people are looking for better ways of saving rather than finding better ways of spending.
Long-term growth strategies must be profitable. If they’re not profitable, then what’s the point?
Nobody wants a credit union full of accounts that do nothing except cost a pile of money to maintain. Loan accounts increase long-term profitability significantly, so it would seem to follow logically that credit unions would primarily target new loan members.
However, an imbalanced loan portfolio carries considerable risk.
If we look at it from a perspective of total member ROI, it’s easy to see why balance is important. A member who takes out a $50,000 mortgage and has a $20,000 deposit balance is better for the credit union’s bottom line than a member who takes out a $100,000 mortgage with no deposit balance.
To capture new leads, it’s important to employ a robust credit union marketing strategy. Consider traditional methods like banner ads and email. Try out content marketing to boost member engagement. Tie the whole thing together with marketing automation.
Just remember that any marketing campaign is an opportunity to bring in new members. Keep your short-term goals and your long-term goals aligned!
Great client service is at the heart of every good business relationship, and credit unions depend a...
It is imperative that your Credit Union has a social media strategy in today’s digital climate. How...
Credit Unions can, and should, be the dominant retail financial services provider in every market in...
Digital payments are not new. PayPal came to life in 1998 as a money transferring platform. By the y...
While optimizing value for clients is the primary focus of credit unions, financial survival also re...
A CEO and consultant’s perspective on voice, AI and digital transformation.